BROWSE CAR REVIEWS BY:

Click on a car body type for search results.
![]() |
![]() |
| SUVs (two rows) | SUVs (three rows) |
![]() |
![]() |
| Crossover | Minivans |
![]() |
![]() |
| Sedan | Hybrids |
![]() |
![]() |
| Wagons/Hatchbacks | Just for Fun |
Choosing the Right Car for Teen Drivers
Jan 19 2009 by Emily Hansen
My son has been driving for about nine months now. Other than a minor parking lot incident involving a larger-than-life trailer hitch that appeared out of nowhere, he’s done very well (I’m knocking on wood as I type). My husband and I are thinking about buying a car for him to help manage the logistical nightmare that occurs when you have three drivers, two cars and no public transportation.
My husband is a firm, old-school believer in buying a big, old car, preferably in the less-than-$500 range. His argument is that more steel makes up for the car’s lack of airbags and other modern safety systems. He also believes that the car should also have a big engine “to allow [our son] to get out of a dangerous situation.”
I’m on the other side of this debate. I don’t mind buying a used car, but the car my precious baby drives better have airbags, antilock brakes and traction control. I also think the car should be on the smallish side, so it’ll be nimble and easy to maneuver. A big engine is out of the question; no teenage boy needs power under his right foot, for multiple reasons.
Even the experts aren’t especially specific. When releasing its annual list of Top Safety Picks, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety consistently says, “Larger, heavier vehicles generally afford more protection than smaller, lighter ones.” Yet every year more cars qualify for the IIHS list in every category, including compact cars.
“The best bet is to buy the newest, most reliable model with the most safety equipment you can afford,” Consumer Reports said in an article about choosing a car for teen drivers in its April 2008 issue.
Our friends at Cars.com (MotherProof.com’s parent site) recommend midsize sedans, hatchbacks and wagons when buying a used car for a teen driver. They even list their picks for the best new and used cars for teens.
In the end, the decision comes down to affordability, but there are some practical considerations that come into play for my family. My son has never driven a car without antilock brakes. I’ve learned from our friends over at Driver’s Edge, a organization that teaches real-life driving skills, that it’s risky to put new drivers in unfamiliar situations. We also live in a place where there could be snow on the road any day between October and April.
The one factor that won’t play a large role in our decision-making process is my son’s dreams about driving a Ford Mustang Shelby GT500. He’ll have to keep that in his dreams, because I’m certain I’ll convince his dad that a smallish, newish, safety-feature-laden, front-wheel-drive sedan is the best choice for our teenage driver.
User Comments
ABS typically carries a $1,000 premium in the new car market, so this is seen in the used car market, as well. Used economy cars are less likely to have this feature, generally 10%, because people shopping for a $12,000 new car don’t have an extra $1,000 to spend. Once in a rare while you might find such a car from a wealthy family that was bought new for a teenage driver, loaded with all the bells and whistles. I was lucky to find such a car in my local classifieds, a ‘95 Corolla with ABS and power everything for less than $3,000, a few years ago that was purchased by the original owner for the shared use of 3 teenagers over 10 years. If this is not possible for you, you should consider an older high-end car, which probably will have the extra safety features, and might still be in the same price range.
when thinking ahead of what specific car to purchase, i’ve always considered choosing not just the affordable one but the car with complete safety features just like with my ford. It’s been three years in me now.. and by now, I got even plans on having some modifications and changing my ford f-250 brush guard. thanks for this helpful info.
I’m with your husband on this one. Buy your son a used Crown Victoria or a Grand Marquis. They have seat belts,air bags,ABS and has alot of metal around it. I’m a woman and I wouldn’t put my teenage son in one of those small cars. Boys need to be boys and and learn to drive a real car.Your husband is also right about a bigger engine to get out of dangerous situations. Believe my V8 Gran Marquis has gotten me out situations wear I would’ve been side swiped and accelerated to avoid an accident.
Liz, You’re my kind of woman!Its refreshing to hear a woman say “Boys need to be boys” these days. Alot of Mothers are way too over protective of their teens,especially boys. I have two 16 year old twin,a boy and a girl and my ex wife is way,way over protective. My son wanted to go out for football,she didn’t want to because he’ll might get hurt.My daughter wanted to try out for cheerlesding,ex wife didn’t want her to because she might have boys trying to pick her up. When they’ll turned 16,they wanted to get their driver’s license,ex wife wanted them to wait till they were 21 to get it. My son & daughter got so sick of her over protectiveness that they asked me last Feb could they live with me. I let them move in, I tuaght them to drive and pass the driver’s test,my son is playing football and my daughter made the cheerleading squad and they both have good marks and do well in school. I can’t afford another 2 cars but I’m thinking about getting them a used Gran Marquis or Crown Vic that they’ll both have to share. They learn with a V8 and learned how to handle it.
Last year,my never married 88 year old uncle who had a 1997 Lincoln Town Car with only 50,000 miles on it decided to give up driving because of his sight. I was visiting him when he walked over threw me the keys and the title and said “Its yours”. So I change it over to my name and my 17 year old son drives it.It has ABS,air bags,all the safety features. Of course I laid rules,no speeding,if he gets a ticket,he pays for and loss of the car for a week,no drugs or booze,which he doesn’t do anyway and if he wants to give a ride to friends,he must call me or his mother and lets know who and where they’ll be going.
My son just got a 1997 Crown Victoria for $1300 from a cowroker of mine. A big car is safe and it has all the features. He is learning to get used to the big car after driving a Taurus and fusion for several months.











Perhaps an almost ten year old Ford Focus, Nissan Sentra, Or a Honda Civic would offer the better compromise in roominess, safety, fuel economy, price, parts availability, and insurance for your teen. Yes, most of these choices are “dorky,” but probably easier on the family budget.